Amish Country, Ohio, offers a slower pace of life under endless cerulean skies. Sample fresh farm-to-table dining, meet friendly locals and gaze upon rolling farmlands as pretty as a picture.
But, the region’s enchantment extends farther than its idyllic surroundings.
Wander through the small towns to find streets lined with boutiques and local markets overflowing with items that showcase pure artisanal talent. From Berlin to Millersburg, Walnut Creek, and beyond, the area of Holmes County boasts remarkable shops selling everything from handicrafts, vintage outdoor furniture, and rare jewelry pieces to kitschy decor.
Bringing the whole family along? Even nana? Everyone is invited to stay with us at Your Family’s Place. Whether you’re planning a grand family gathering or an intimate retreat, our multi-generational rentals serve as a perfect base for your exploration and for getting a taste of the simple Amish way of life.
And what better way to keep these memories alive than by taking home a keepsake unique to Amish Country?
Let’s explore the top stores where you can purchase memorable souvenirs to remind you of your getaway.
1. Village Gift Barn
- Address: 4755 OH-39, Berlin, OH
- Best for: Home Decor, Quirky Jewelry, Souvenirs, Vintage Fashion
Originally a dairy barn, the Village Gift Barn has transformed into a destination drawing all types of shoppers for over two decades. It now occupies a vast 20,000-square-foot space. As a part of Berlin’s Sheiyah Market, this gift shop is a one-stop shop for all things tasteful. Their collection of homeware, kitchenware, interior decor, and fashion goods is exceptional! We won’t blame you if you find yourself inspired to refresh both your wardrobe and living space with their unique finds.
Past shoppers rave about Village Gift Barn’s fantastic selection and welcoming atmosphere, further enhanced by their super-friendly staff. Not only are they knowledgeable about the products, but they are also eager to share stories about the Amish everyday life.
2. Country Gatherings
- Address: 4755 OH-39, Berlin, OH
- Best for: Art Pieces, Candles, Primitive Decor, Religion-themed products
Another gem inside the lively Sheiyah Market, Country Gatherings, feels less like a general store and more like an art museum. Along with peddling the usual suspects like antique furniture, sculptures, clothes, and jewelry, they also have stunning apothecary oils up for grabs. While the products come at a hefty price tag, the quality and curation more than justify the cost.
Have a loved one who’s a cottagecore devotee back home? Bring their Pinterest dream to life with a rustic planter or candle set from Country Gatherings.
3. Walnut Creek Marketplace
- Address: 1900 OH-39, Sugarcreek, OH
- Best for: International Goods, Wooden Items, Seasonal Snacks, Beverages
A pet-friendly flea market unlike any other, the Walnut Creek Marketplace deserves at least half a morning of your time. Don’t come looking for second-hand fashion or furniture— there isn’t much of that. Instead, you’ll find a plethora of unique items, like handcrafted toys, soaps, tasty snacks, and drinks, all from original vendors!
Make sure to pick up jars of Hot Pepper Jelly; it’s a hit among all visitors! And don’t forget about seasonal snacks and drinks, like the pumpkin spice latte in the fall and the winter favorite peppermint drinks — they taste like Christmas in a cup.
Popular vendors include A&G Tabletop Creations, known for their exquisitely crocheted items; Amish Country Gourmet, where you can taste tempting snacks, sauces, and desserts; and Amish Country Soap Co, which offers a line of 100% natural bathing products.
4. Tis the Season Christmas Shoppe
- Address: 4363 OH-39, Millersburg, OH
- Best for: Christmas Ornaments, Christmas Tree, Fairy Lights, Nutcrackers
No matter the season outside, the Christmas spirit is alive all year round at Tis the Season Shoppe. This dreamy three-floored wonderland is perfect for nabbing a few noël-themed items to take the festive magic back home. Browse their charming holiday decorations, presents, and even majestic Christmas trees.
As a haven for Christmas aficionados, the shop has everything from classic traditional ornaments and Santa masks to whimsical holiday-themed items. But buyers, be warned: the merchandise is so adorable it will likely catch your attention, win over your hearts, and perhaps encourage a few extra purchases.
5. Helping Hands Quilt Shop
- Address: 4818 OH-39, Berlin, OH
- Best for: Handmade Quilts, Tools for Quilting, Colorful Fabrics, Wall Hangings
For people new to quilting or in search of a beautiful, finished quilt, Helping Hands Quilt Shop is ready to meet your needs.
Established in the 70s, this homegrown store is proud of its 100% Mennonite quilts. They have over 100 quilts available for purchase, featuring gorgeous geometric patterns in a spectrum of colors. Plus, the shelves at Helping Hands Quilt Shop are brimming with quilting tools.
Whether you’re starting your first project or are a seasoned quilter looking for advanced equipment, you’ll find what you need here. Smaller items like art pieces, pillows, and table runners are also available for purchase, making it easy to find that perfect Amish Country souvenir to take back home.
6. Main Street Fudge & Popcorn Company
- Address: 4799 E Main St, Millersburg, OH
- Best for: Fudge, Popcorn, Taffy, Candy, Ice Cream
Craving a sweet souvenir? Get your fix at Main Street Fudge & Popcorn Company.
If Willy Wonka had a popcorn factory, this would be it. As soon as you walk in, the aroma of freshly popped kernels wafts and entices your tastebuds. Expect to be blown away by the number of popcorn flavors vying for your attention. Although you can’t sample before buying, we’re sure any selection will make your tastebuds dance with joy. Don’t miss out on the Caramel Corn with Almonds and Peanuts — a serious crowd pleaser.
Traveling with kids? This store is a must-visit. Children will love picking from the sheer variety of sweet treats like cotton candy, fudge, salt water taffy, and fun soda flavors. With multicolor interiors and bright decor—and a perfect location on Main Street of Berlin—this photogenic spot deserves a short but sweet visit.
7. Berlin Antique Mall
- Address: 4359 OH-39, Millersburg, OH
- Best for: Antiques, Books, Coins, Faux Animal Heads, Glassware
Do you relish historical and curated finds? The Berlin Antique Mall has a large selection to dig through. Discover their messily displayed but extensive selection of antiques, vintage items, outdoor furniture, glassware, and home decor.
Set in the heart of Berlin, this mall serves as a portal into the past and a rare opportunity to find one-of-a-kind pieces for your home. The collection changes often, so visiting Berlin Antique Mall during every visit to Ohio’s Amish Country is recommended for fresh finds.
Shop Your Heart Out in Ohio’s Amish Country
Friendly faces, countless opportunities to shop till you drop, and stunning accommodations amid lush landscapes await you in Amish Country, Ohio—the perfect formula for an escape from urban life’s noise and crowd.
Reserve your stay with Your Family’s Place and find a second home in the heart of Amish Country. Pack light, as our comprehensive list of amenities leaves plenty of room in your suitcase for souvenir finds!
