Ohio’s Amish Country is a cornucopia of great food made with fresh ingredients, organic meats from the deli, and the kind of regional food that you just can’t find back home.
A stay with Your Family’s Place will put you in the middle of the best of them!
We’ve curated this list of 7 of our absolute favorite restaurants in Ohio Amish Country. These standout spots not only offer mouthwatering home-cooked meals, but they also serve them against the serene backdrop of the area’s beautiful countryside.
Hungry and intrigued? Good, let’s get exploring!
Rebecca’s Bistro
- Address: 4986 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH
- Favorite menu item: Bacon, Spinach, Mushroom Quiche
- Price point: $$
What if we told you that there is a restaurant in Walnut Creek, Ohio, with an interior that looks like the world’s cutest log cabin? Now what if we told you that said place has been known to serve up an acclaimed selection of Quiche?
Hopefully, you’ll believe us, but you may just have to visit Rebecca’s Bistro yourself. Who knows, maybe after you’ve sipped on their iconically smooth espresso and stuffed yourself with their hearty sandwiches, you’ll become a believer like us.
Rebecca’s prides itself on being a “Gathering of Friends.” So, if you want to dine at a quaint spot that embodies the heart and people of the region, this is your ticket.
Dutch Valley Restaurant
- Address: 1343 Old Route 39 Northeast, Sugarcreek, OH, USA
- Favorite menu item: Roast Beef
- Price point: $$
Where’s the beef? The roast beef, that is. To be honest, you’ll find it in a lot of places around Amish Country. But the most quality stuff? That’s at Dutch Valley.
The restaurant, conveniently located between a gift shop and a market, is celebrated for its tender roast beef and velvety mashed potatoes, which you can enjoy while listening to passing buggies. Seriously, it’s that country.
Suppose that’s not alluring enough for you, fair enough. But, the rest of us will be strolling through the picturesque hillsides of a region known as Little Switzerland, that’s right, walking off the five pounds of perfected beef we just consumed at Dutch Valley.
Der Dutchman Restaurant
- Address: 4967 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH
- Favorite menu item: Broasted Chicken
- Price point: $$
Look, if you’re going to visit Amish Country, you should really try to eat at an establishment that shows off how beautiful the area is, right?
Thankfully, there’s the Der Dutchman, a cozy family-style restaurant that offers sprawling views of Holmes County’s natural allure and homegrown eats. Think Ham & Bean Soup and country store style pies. Der Dutchman also has weekly rotating specials.
The restaurant’s bakery and buffet are notable highlights, with an abundance of praise heaped on the staff. Did we mention that they have old-timey rocking chairs on their front porch? Perfect for transporting you to a simpler time.
Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen
- Address: 8101 State Route 241, Mt Hope, OH 44660
- Favorite menu item: Fried Chicken
- Price point: $$
Trying to catch a vibe that feels like a warm embrace from grandma? Then visit Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen in Mt. Hope and have local legend Gloria Yoder serve you up a wholesome Amish Country feast.
Located in the hustle and bustle of the Mt. Hope Livestock Auction, the acclaimed kitchen is one of Ohio’s Amish Country’s most beloved spots for comfort food. Fried chicken? Yes, please! It’s been supplying visitors and locals with mouth-watering fried chicken recipes since 1994!
The menu? A treasure trove of fried chicken, roast beef, pork chops, and perch. Oh, and homemade pies, you can’t forget about those little delights.
Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant
- Address: 4819 East Main Street, Berlin, OH
- Favorite menu item: Hot Roast Beef Sandwich with Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
- Price point: $$
Want to go where the locals go? Head over to Boyd & Wurthmann’s, folks—a place so steeped in history that its flavors are literally tradition at this point. The same goes for the decor, which can easily transport you into the simpler times of the past.
From its humble beginnings as Hummel’s Market to becoming the go-to diner everyone adores, it’s a spot with a better origin story than most sports teams.
Its real charm, however, lies in its authenticity. Diners are seated at the diner’s original green countertops, a staple since the 1940s, offering a unique touch of history you simply won’t find at chain diners.
So, why not embrace the 70-year legacy of Boyd & Wurthmann on your next jaunt to Amish Country? It’s not just a meal; it’s a memorable journey into the heart of local tradition
Berlin Farmstead Restaurant
- Address: 4757 Township Rd 366, Berlin, OH
- Favorite menu item: Swiss Meatloaf
- Price point: $$
We are not blowing smoke when we tell you that making a pit stop at Berlin’s Farmstead is an absolute must for foodies and families visiting Amish Country. Not only does the little slice of heritage heaven offer panoramic views of Berlin’s rolling hills. It also whips up quality homestyle meals.
Go for the Turkey Manhattan—a pippin’ hot Turkey sandwich with a generous helping of gravy-smothered mashed potatoes. And for dessert, a bowl of seasonal fruits or freshly baked peanut butter cookies is the perfect finale.
In short, this place is your golden ticket to slowing down and soaking in good vibes. So, rally the troops, find a spot at one of their tables, and let the authentic flavors and rural Ohio’s genuine hospitality warm you up!
The Amish Door Restaurant
- Address: 210 Winesburg St, Wilmot, OH
- Favorite menu item: Homemade Mashed Potatoes topped with Noodles and Gravy
- Price point: $$
With a name like The Amish Door, we know it’s not surprising to learn this place has quite the knack for elevating Traditional Amish dishes.
Menu highlights? This place has those in spades. From its homemade mashed potatoes and fried chicken to an All-You-Can-Eat Salad Bar, The Amish Door does it all.
First launched in 1977, the Amish Door has evolved from a modest 48-seat eatery into a beloved village, maintaining its commitment to quality and excellence. Renowned for its hearty buffet and signature broasted chicken dinners, it’s a staple for locals and visitors alike.
Eat Your Heart Out in Ohio’s Amish Country
Well, there you have it—our roundup of the best dining spots in Ohio’s Amish Country.
Book your stay with Your Family’s Place and say hello to places like Boyd & Wurthmann’s, Der Dutchman’s, and Berlin’s Farmstead, where authentic flavors and heartwarming hospitality await.
